Verifying Information

Introduction

This workshop aims to develop awareness of how to properly verify information and its sources more broadly.

This is a workshop that requires everyone to actively participate. In the end, participants will answer questions one by one.

The goal will be to find out whether they are aware of current events and if not, why not.

Facilitation tips: 

We recommend you be aware of important current affairs in the week leading up to the workshop. You should be able to identify 5-10 things that happened the previous week, whether that be in a national context or globally. A good variety of sources and information types would be effective (printed news, videos, news relevant over several days etc.)

This can be complemented by these other workshops from Digital Travelers:

• Defining a Source
• Monitoring Info with Twitter
• Customizing Verification Tools with Feedly or Flipboard

 

Discussion

Ask the group to name the three most important news stories have been this week. This is not always obvious so be aware of 5-10 issues or stores to name.

It could happen one of two ways. You could either ask participants to say their answers out loud directly or have them them write them down first.

Ask them to specify where they heard, read or saw the news named. If you have one, right all the different sources on the board. It is best that participants have already completed to workshop ‘Understanding a Source’. If they haven’t, have it a look at it yourself and briefly explain the concept of a source.

The goal is to get a sense of how aware the group is of current affairs. Are they only aware of their own areas of interest (culture, sports, etc.) or are they broader awareness?

 

Getting reliable news

Next ask participants to go to the computers by groups of three.

Ask them to search for three key stories from that day (or the day before if it’s still early!). Suggest they check they check some of hte following:

• Social media (e.g. Twitter)
• News sites (e.g. Guardian, New York Times, etc.)
• Blogs
• Newsletters
• News aggregators (e.g. Google News)

After 15-20 minutes of searching, ask them to:

• Cite the three key points or stories they found
• Cite the sources (which you can write on the board next to the sources mentioned in the previous exercise)
• Say whether they have found other ways of informing themselves
• Compare the three key stories before and after researching. Have they changed? If so why?

This exercise should show why it is important to refer to a diverse range of sources when researching what is going on the news in general or indeed on any particular subject. We can at this point give some advice on how to go about this.

Comparing what you have before and after the research also allows you to understand how valuable it is to inform yourself critically and effectively – how making the effort to research well can influence our perception of what is happening (or not if there are no obvious changes!)

 

Knowing the news

Ask participants to write a short paragraph (around 5 lines) on one of the key news items they selected during the previous exercise. Allow 5 minutes for this.

Ask each to read theirs. A good way to approach this would be to follow each reading up with questions on the missing information. What you want to know is: what is it they are talking about, when did it happen, who or what does it concern, how or why did it happen, in what conditions and where?

If possible, nudge them out of their comfort zone. Demand more detail or ask them to contextualise further.

If goal of this exercise is to show that just because we vaguely heard about something doesn’t mean we know it. The idea is to always reflect and think critically about we think we know and, when something is important, we should make an effort to inform ourselves well.